Cheapest Car Insurance in Caldwell, ID – 2025 Rates and Rankings

Looking for the cheapest car insurance in Caldwell, Idaho? See which cars, pickups, and SUVs tend to be the most affordable to insure.

Start a Free QuoteCompare Caldwell car insurance quotes and save on your next policy.

Top 30 cheapest cars to insure in Caldwell

The vehicles with the best auto insurance quotes in Caldwell, ID, tend to be crossovers and small SUVs like the Chevrolet Trailblazer, Subaru Crosstrek, Buick Envision, and Toyota Corolla Cross.

Average auto insurance prices for models ranked in the top 10 cost $1,616 or less per year, or $135 per month, for full coverage.

Examples of other models that are highly ranked in our cost comparison are the Volkswagen Tiguan, Volkswagen Taos, Buick Envista, and Honda CR-V. Insurance is slightly more for those models than the compact SUVs that rank near the top, but they still have an average insurance cost of $1,714 or less per year in Caldwell.

The table below ranks the top 30 models with the cheapest car insurance rates in Caldwell, sorted by average cost.

Cheapest Auto Insurance Rates in Caldwell
Rank Make/Model Annual Premium Cost Per Month
1Subaru Crosstrek$1,416$118
2Chevrolet Trailblazer$1,444$120
3Kia Soul$1,500$125
4Nissan Kicks$1,510$126
5Honda Passport$1,524$127
6Buick Envision$1,534$128
7Toyota Corolla Cross$1,548$129
8Hyundai Venue$1,558$130
9Mazda CX-5$1,562$130
10Ford Bronco Sport$1,572$131
11Volkswagen Tiguan$1,584$132
12Acura RDX$1,600$133
13Nissan Murano$1,612$134
14Buick Encore$1,630$136
15Subaru Outback$1,632$136
16Honda CR-V$1,636$136
17Buick Envista$1,642$137
18Volkswagen Taos$1,642$137
19Kia Niro$1,652$138
20Toyota GR Corolla$1,662$139
21Subaru Ascent$1,664$139
22Honda HR-V$1,668$139
23Nissan Leaf$1,680$140
24Chevrolet Colorado$1,688$141
25Lexus NX 250$1,694$141
26Honda Civic$1,696$141
27Volkswagen Atlas$1,696$141
28Acura Integra$1,704$142
29Subaru Forester$1,704$142
30Volkswagen Atlas Cross Sport$1,706$142

Data Methodology: Rated driver is a 40-year-old married male with no driving violations or at-fault accidents in the prior three years. Uninsured Motorist (UM), Underinsured Motorist (UIM) and medical payments coverages are included. Premium is averaged for all trim levels available for each vehicle and also for all Caldwell, ID Zip Codes. Updated June 26, 2025

Top 30 cheapest vehicles to insure in Caldwell, ID with the Subaru Crosstrek ranking first at $1,416 per year
Top 30 cheapest vehicles to insure in Caldwell, ID with the Subaru Crosstrek ranking first at $1,416 per year

Additional vehicles making the list of the top 30 above include the Subaru Ascent, Honda Civic, Chevrolet Colorado, Acura Integra, and Subaru Forester. Insurance rates for those models fall between $1,714 and $1,758 per year in Caldwell.

To put the rates for the cheapest vehicles in perspective, a few models that have much higher car insurance rates include the Toyota Mirai that costs $2,450 per year, the Ram Truck that averages $2,280, and the BMW X3 which averages $2,324.

What is average car insurance cost in Caldwell?

In Caldwell, the average cost to insure a vehicle is $1,974 per year, which is 11.8% less than the overall national average rate of $2,221. Per month, Caldwell car insurance costs about $165 per month for a policy with full coverage.

In the state of Idaho, the average cost of car insurance is $1,974 per year, so the cost in Caldwell is very similar to the state as a whole. The cost to insure a car in Caldwell compared to other Idaho locations is about $48 per year cheaper than in Idaho Falls, $30 per year less than in Pocatello, and $4 per year more expensive than in Nampa.

The age of the rated driver is the largest factor that influences the cost of auto insurance, so the list below details how age impacts cost by breaking out average car insurance rates in Caldwell depending on driver age.

Average car insurance cost for Caldwell drivers age 16 to 60

  • 16-year-old driver – $7,020 per year or $585 per month
  • 17-year-old driver – $6,801 per year or $567 per month
  • 18-year-old driver – $6,095 per year or $508 per month
  • 19-year-old driver – $5,553 per year or $463 per month
  • 20-year-old driver – $3,966 per year or $331 per month
  • 30-year-old driver – $2,102 per year or $175 per month
  • 40-year-old driver – $1,974 per year or $165 per month
  • 50-year-old driver – $1,748 per year or $146 per month
  • 60-year-old driver – $1,638 per year or $137 per month

The chart below shows average auto insurance cost in Caldwell broken out not only by driver age, but also by policy deductibles. Rates are averaged for all 2024 vehicle models including luxury brand cars and SUVs.

Average full-coverage car insurance premium in Caldwell, ID for different ages of drivers.
Figure 1: Average full-coverage car insurance premium in Caldwell, ID for different ages of drivers. Rates updated on June 26, 2025.

Get Rates in Your AreaWhy is this important?

Data Methodology: Average premiums are based on all 2024 model year vehicles. Rates assume a clean driving record and no claims or at-fault accidents. Comprehensive and collision coverage is included as well as UM/UIM and medical payments coverage. Premiums are averaged across all Caldwell, ID Zip Codes.

Average Car Insurance Cost in Caldwell, ID
Driver Age Deductible Annual Premium Cost Per Month
20$1,000$3,356$280
$500$3,966$331
$250$4,614$385
30$1,000$1,764$147
$500$2,102$175
$250$2,458$205
40$1,000$1,660$138
$500$1,974$165
$250$2,300$192
50$1,000$1,478$123
$500$1,748$146
$250$2,030$169
60$1,000$1,384$115
$500$1,638$137
$250$1,902$159

Data Methodology: Rated driver is a 40-year-old married male with no driving violations or at-fault accidents in the prior three years. Uninsured Motorist (UM), Underinsured Motorist (UIM) and medical payments coverages are included. Premium is averaged for all Caldwell, ID Zip Codes. Updated June 26, 2025

Average car insurance rates in the previous chart range from $1,384 per year for a high deductible policy for a 60-year-old driver to $4,614 per year for a 20-year-old driver with a low deductible policy.

From a monthly budgeting standpoint, the average cost of car insurance per month in Caldwell ranges from $115 to $385.

Caldwell car insurance rates can cost very different amounts for different drivers and can also be very different depending on the company. Due to the fact that rates are so variable, this emphasizes the need to get accurate auto insurance quotes when shopping around for cheaper coverage.

The section below details the average cost to insure each different vehicle segment. The average rates shown should give a good understanding of the types of vehicles that have the cheapest auto insurance rates in Caldwell. Then the subsequent sections rank the 20 cheapest models in each automotive segment.

Best vehicles for the cheapest insurance rates

If you’re shopping around for a new or used car, it’s useful to know which kinds of vehicles cost less to insure. Buying a vehicle with cheap car insurance rates can possibly fit a more expensive car payment into your monthly budget.

For instance, maybe you want to know if compact cars have cheaper auto insurance than midsize cars or if full-size SUVs are more expensive to insure than midsize or compact SUVs.

The next chart displays average car insurance cost by vehicle segment in Caldwell. When comparing rates from a segment perspective, compact SUVs, midsize trucks, and minivans tend to have the best rates, while exotic performance cars have the most expensive overall rates.

Car insurance average cost by automotive segment in Caldwell, ID.
Figure 2: Car insurance average cost by automotive segment in Caldwell, ID. Rates updated on June 26, 2025.

Data Methodology: Car insurance premium by automotive segment is based on 2024 model year vehicles. The rated driver is a 40-year-old male with no driving violations or at-fault accidents in the prior three years. Comprehensive and collision deductibles are $500 and rates are averaged for all Caldwell Zip Codes.

Car Insurance Rates by Automotive Segment in Caldwell, ID
Automotive Segment Annual Premium Cost Per Month
Compact SUV$1,814$151
Midsize SUV$1,946$162
Compact Car$1,948$162
Minivan$1,950$163
Midsize Pickup$1,990$166
Midsize Car$2,012$168
Compact Luxury SUV$2,136$178
Compact Luxury Car$2,170$181
Large SUV$2,176$181
Half-ton Pickup$2,184$182
Heavy Duty Pickup$2,266$189
Midsize Luxury SUV$2,342$195
Midsize Luxury Car$2,420$202
Sports Car$2,710$226
Large Car$2,834$236
Large Luxury SUV$3,052$254
Large Luxury Car$3,154$263

Data Methodology: Rated driver is a 40-year-old married male with no driving violations or at-fault accidents in the prior three years. Uninsured Motorist (UM), Underinsured Motorist (UIM) and medical payments coverages are included. Premium is averaged for all 2024 model year vehicles and also for all Caldwell, ID Zip Codes. Updated June 26, 2025

Average insurance rates by segment are accurate enough for getting an initial comparison, but rates range significantly within each automotive segment displayed in the previous chart.

For example, in the midsize car segment, Caldwell auto insurance rates range from the Kia K5 at $1,896 per year for a full coverage policy up to the Tesla Model 3 costing $2,316 per year. As another example, in the large luxury car segment, the average insurance cost can range from the Audi A5 costing $2,342 per year up to the Mercedes-Benz Maybach S680 costing $4,126 per year, a difference of $1,784 within that segment.

In the next list, we detail the model with the best car insurance rates in Caldwell, ID, for each segment. Annual and monthly average insurance quotes are shown for each model.

  • Cheapest compact car to insureToyota GR Corolla at $1,714 per year or $143 per month
  • Cheapest compact SUV to insureSubaru Crosstrek at $1,458 per year or $122 per month
  • Cheapest midsize car to insureKia K5 at $1,896 per year or $158 per month
  • Cheapest midsize SUV to insureHonda Passport at $1,570 per year or $131 per month
  • Cheapest full-size car to insureChrysler 300 at $1,878 per year or $157 per month
  • Cheapest full-size SUV to insureChevrolet Tahoe at $1,854 per year or $155 per month
  • Cheapest midsize pickup to insureChevrolet Colorado at $1,736 per year or $145 per month
  • Cheapest full-size pickup to insureNissan Titan at $1,844 per year or $154 per month
  • Cheapest heavy duty pickup to insureGMC Sierra 2500 HD at $2,008 per year or $167 per month
  • Cheapest minivan to insureHonda Odyssey at $1,802 per year or $150 per month
  • Cheapest sports car to insureMazda MX-5 Miata at $1,826 per year or $152 per month
  • Cheapest compact luxury car to insureAcura Integra at $1,754 per year or $146 per month
  • Cheapest compact luxury SUV to insureAcura RDX at $1,650 per year or $138 per month
  • Cheapest midsize luxury car to insureMercedes-Benz CLA250 at $2,030 per year or $169 per month
  • Cheapest midsize luxury SUV to insureJaguar E-Pace at $1,844 per year or $154 per month
  • Cheapest full-size luxury car to insureAudi A5 at $2,342 per year or $195 per month
  • Cheapest full-size luxury SUV to insureInfiniti QX80 at $2,212 per year or $184 per month

The car insurance rates discussed up to this point are averaged for all 2024 vehicle models, which is handy for making generalized comparisons like the cost difference between two locations.

Average auto insurance rates are great for getting the answer to questions like “is car insurance cheaper in Caldwell or Meridian?” or “is Idaho car insurance cheaper than Texas?”.

But for more useful cost comparisons, we should do a rate analysis for the specific vehicle being insured. Each individual model has it’s own exposure profile for car insurance rating and this data provides the means to perform better insurance cost comparisons.

This next chart displays average insurance rates for popular cars, trucks, and SUVs bought and insured in Caldwell. Some, like the Mazda CX-5 and Honda CR-V are ranked in the top 30 table from earlier in the article, but most popular models did not make the top rankings.

Average cost to insure popular 2024 model year vehicles in Caldwell.
Figure 3: Average cost to insure popular 2024 model year vehicles in Caldwell. Rates updated on June 27, 2025.

Data Methodology: Average car insurance cost is based on 2024 model year vehicles with safe driver and claim-free discounts applied. Comprehensive and collision deductibles are $500 and UM/UIM and medical payments coverages are included. Rates are averaged for all Caldwell Zip Codes.

Average Car Insurance Quotes for Popular Vehicles in Caldwell, ID
Make/Model Annual Premium Cost Per Month
Mazda CX-5$1,610$134
Honda CR-V$1,682$140
Nissan Rogue$1,768$147
Mazda CX-30$1,776$148
Ford Escape$1,798$150
Toyota RAV4$1,818$152
Chevrolet Traverse$1,838$153
Honda Accord$1,904$159
Kia Forte$1,926$161
Jeep Grand Cherokee$1,974$165
Hyundai Santa Fe$2,006$167
Toyota 4Runner$2,112$176
Toyota Camry$2,120$177
Hyundai Elantra$2,142$179
Ford Mustang$2,164$180
Chevrolet Silverado$2,180$182
Ford Bronco$2,186$182
Ford F150$2,204$184
Tesla Model 3$2,316$193
Chevrolet Corvette$2,730$228

Data Methodology: Rated driver is a 40-year-old married male with no driving violations or at-fault accidents in the prior three years. Uninsured Motorist (UM), Underinsured Motorist (UIM) and medical payments coverages are included. Premium is averaged for all trim levels available for each vehicle for the 2024 model year and also for all Caldwell, ID Zip Codes. Updated June 27, 2025

Only a handful of the popular models in the chart above ranked in the top 30 for cheapest insurance rates.

This higher cost could be due to buying a pricey vehicle, like a Chevrolet Corvette with an average purchase price of $69,995 or a Porsche Taycan that has an average price of $90,900.

Another reason could be the higher chance of liability or medical claims like on a Mazda 3, Volkswagen Jetta, or Kia Rio. Some models just have higher likelihood of having substantial claims due to design or safety issues.

Saving money on auto insurance

Caldwell drivers are always looking to cut the monthly cost of insurance, so take a minute to review the money-saving ideas in this next list and it’s very likely you can save a little dough on your next policy.

  • Be a safe driver and save on Caldwell car insurance. Being the cause of frequent accidents will raise rates, potentially up to $2,814 per year for a 20-year-old driver and even as much as $480 per year for a 60-year-old driver. So drive safe and save money!
  • Get cheaper insurance cost by avoiding traffic tickets. In order to get cheap car insurance in Caldwell, it’s necessary to drive safe. Just a few speeding tickets have the potential to raise insurance policy cost by as much as $522 per year. Major infractions such as DUI/DWI and leaving the scene of an accident could raise rates by an additional $1,830 or more.
  • Better credit scores yield better car insurance rates. Having a good credit rating over 800 could save up to $310 per year versus a slightly lower credit score between 670-739. Conversely, a lesser credit rating could cost around $359 more per year. Not all states use credit score as a rating factor, so check with your agent or company.
  • Compare insurance costs before buying a car. Different models, and even different trim levels of the same model, have very different costs for insurance, and insurance companies can price policies with a wide range of prices. Check prices before you buy so you can avoid any surprises when you receive your bill.
  • Remain claim free. Insurance companies give a discounted rate if you do not file any claims. Auto insurance should only be used in the case of large financial hits, not minor claims.
  • Choose vehicles that have cheaper auto insurance. The performance of the vehicle you drive is a big factor in the price you pay for car insurance. As an example, a Kia Sportage costs $1,036 less per year to insure in Caldwell than a Dodge Challenger. Lower performance vehicles cost less to insure.